Travis Bruno of Capsule Computers writes:
"The amount of anime comedies that involve a group of girls or a small gathering of students at a high school mostly doing things in their club room is astounding. The thing is, despite there being so many series that follow this path, many turn out to be very successful. Based off of a ten volume light novel series that ended a few years ago and received numerous spin-offs, Student Council’s Discretion has now made its way to North America courtesy of Sentai Filmworks. So, does this series have what it takes to be considered a success or is it something to simply ignore?"