Richard of PopCults.com writes "Still, as nonsensical as the stories may seem, as (seemingly) perverted as some of the notions in Cute High Earth Defense Club LOVE! may sometimes be – and believe you me, there are some scenes that had me going WTF!? – there is a deeper story here than what you are seeing on the surface. Yes, this is a parody of the magical girl genre, and to a certain degree the Yaoi genre in some degree, but it does a great deal to respect the genre while poking fun at it the whole way. It seems like a stupid idea on the surface, but it is intelligently conceived and written for fans of the genre, and of the anime art form as a whole to enjoy. This one is for the boys, and for the girls as well."