Travis Bruno of Capsule Computers writes:
"When it comes to shoujo based series, many viewers tend to write them off as being fairly predictable and while this is true in some cases, as we’ve seen in recent years the shoujo genre has come quite a long way. In fact, Sentai Filmworks’ release of My Love Story!! in North America is proof of that concept. With the company opting to release the entire twenty four episode series in one package, viewers are in for quite a lot of content here but does this unique love story play out in a satisfying manner?"