Travis Bruno of Capsule Computers writes:
"kimi ni todoke -From Me to You- Volume 2 continues to deliver the same charming experience found in Volume 1. The premium edition itself may be a bit light on extra content but still delivers a charming themed artbook, though the lack of any on-disc extras is a bit of a negative. With a likable cast of characters, especially Sawako and her two female friends, and an enjoyable storyline the show’s slow progression doesn’t harm it in the slightest. In fact, with a third release on the way, the great impression Volume 2 leaves on viewers will leave them eager to see more of Sawako’s life and interactions with those around her."